Discussion about this post

User's avatar
CStollenwerk's avatar

All of us readers must be so dumb, because "The Marginal Voter is Always Revenged" SLAPS as a title

Tarb's avatar
Oct 7Edited

"Paxton’s supporters are still trying to scrape together a win from the table scraps, and they could still pull it off, since Texas is still plenty red… but Texas is not Wyoming. It is no longer a state where you can nominate any jokester with an R next to his name and expect the voters to give your guy the flag lapel (if it ever was)."

It's especially worth remembering that Alabama, which is markedly more conservative than Texas (Trump won Alabama by a good amount more than Texas), still voted in a Democratic Senator when the Republican nominee was bad enough.

Granted, Roy Moore was an even worse candidate than Ken Paxton, and the Democrats were fortunate enough that their nominee was a moderate without Talarico's baggage. If it had been Talarico vs. Paxton in Alabama back then, Paxton would have won. But because Texas isn't as staunchly Republican as Alabama, it means you don't need things to be as extreme as they were in Alabama for the Democrat to win.

I should also point out that if the Democrats had chosen a candidate without James Talarico's baggage, they'd probably actually be cruising to a victory here. Beta O'Rourke came close to beating Ted Cruz who was a much stronger candidate than Paxton; if Democrats had someone like that, they'd be in a good position, rather than the current position of it being a toss up. That said, the other choice in the primary was Jasmine Crockett who would've been a harder sell in a general election than Talarico, so Democratic voters chose the stronger candidate there. The primary system might be to blame that it came down to candidates who weren't all that great for Democrats, but at least the Democratic electorate (unlike the Republican electorate) was smart enough to choose the stronger candidate.

One thing that I don't think I've seen many comment on is that Paxton is not only dragging down the Texas election, but other elections. If John Cornyn had been the nominee, he would've beaten Talarico pretty easily, and Republican groups could have put their money and focus for other elections and other states. But because Texas is suddenly a toss up, Republican groups have to spend a bunch of money and energy to win that election... money and energy they can't spent on other races. Even if Paxton pulls off a win, his nomination still hurt Republicans in that other races became closer... and of course if he loses, it means not only did the Republicans lose a Senate seat, they ALSO harmed other races as a result.

16 more comments...

Ready for more?