Nitpick: You're right on the timing of the shift to selection of Presidential candidates via primary elections, but their use for selecting candidates in other US elections long predates their use in Presidential elections. Smith v. Allwright was decided in 1944, and primary elections had been in place for quite some time in many places as of that decision. (For instance, Wisconsin introduced primary elections in 1904 after approval in a statewide referendum, supported by, among others, incumbent Republican Governor Robert M. La Follette--yes, I can hear you saying that issue referenda are bad, and I wouldn't disagree with you, though I might cite different examples and reasons--and prior to that the Deep South had been using them as a way of keeping blacks from participating in selecting Democratic Party candidates, which was tantamount to barring them from the election, since that area had been on a slide toward one-party rule since the federal Congress restored passive suffrage to most of those stripped of it by the 14th Amendment.)
Primaries are still bad and have led to, as you know I've argued, the entrenchment of the two major parties in the US (though, interestingly, one of the stronger third-party presences in the US pretty much right up until McCarthyism was in Milwaukee, where Socialist candidates often won by campaigning on public-works project successes like the city's sewer system, leading other members of the Socialist Party to deride the Milwaukee socialists as "sewer socialists"; you may recognize a modern analogue with Zohran Mamdani's program to fill New York City's potholes, and he has himself drawn the comparison, calling it "pothole politics", the theory being that everyone hates potholes and it's politically difficult to make a counterargument to the proposition that spending city funds on filling potholes is good), and I get frustrated every time I see people with whom I agree on many policy questions argue for what I view as a continued undermining of necessary counterdemocratic checks via things like the introduction of binding candidate-selection primaries (in one particular case, even as she vociferously defends others, largely because, from what I can tell, the one produces policy results she dislikes and the other results she likes), but if anything they've been doing damage for much longer than you suggest here!
It occurs to me that all you'd have to change about the sentence where you mention the origin of primary elections (aside from changing the links) is changing "help George McGovern" to "disenfranchise black voters". They have indeed since wreaked little but evil.
I have belatedly tried to edit the sentence to read:
Statewide primaries were invented to disenfranchise Black voters, nationalized simply to help George McGovern, and, naturally, have wreaked little but evil ever since.
With this footnote:
UPDATE 10 November 2026: This sentence originally read, “They were invented by the Democratic Party to help George McGovern, and, naturally, have wreaked little but evil ever since.” My right honorable friend Daniel Pareja noted in the comments that this was blending primaries au général with the binding presidential primaries that arose with the McGovern “reforms,” and suggested this expansion. I removed the slam on the Democrats because it seemed rude, at least in this context, to slam Democrats for racism they perpetrated 130 years ago.
...however, Substack is refusing the save the change. "Network issues." Hopefully it will go through in the morning.
I remember years ago seeing a Jim Crow-era voter registration form from (I think) Louisiana (maybe it was Mississippi or Alabama), probably from the 1950s or early 1960s (so after Smith v. Allwright, but before the Voting Rights Act). I didn't have the necessary cultural context to understand what was so odd about it at the time, nor did I fully appreciate the explanation that accompanied it, again because of that lack of cultural context. Sadly, I can't find said image now.
What would look odd about it to a modern viewer who does have that context is that despite the state's having partisan primaries, the voter registration form contained no place where the voter could indicate desired party affiliation. I didn't appreciate the full import of this when I saw it initially, but in retrospect of course it is clear: it was a way for election officials to ensure that the only people who got to register as members of the Democratic Party, and thus vote in its primaries (still tantamount to the general election at the time), were whites. Suffice it to say that Dixiecrats were perpetrating election racism pretty much right up until northern Democrats and Republicans forced them to stop.
“I said, ‘Quite a day, Mr President.’ As he reached a sheaf of the wire copy he tilted his head slightly back and held the copy up close to him so that he could read it, and said: ‘Well, I think we may have lost the south for your lifetime – and mine.’
“It was lightly said. Not sarcastic. Not even dramatically. It was like a throwaway sidebar.”
Moyers died in 2025.
In 2026, voters in Texas, Georgia, South Carolina, North Carolina, and possibly Mississippi elected Democratic Senators and the party made significant electoral gains across the region.
"Primaries are still bad and have led to, as you know I've argued, the entrenchment of the two major parties in the US"
Can you explain how this is the case? The problem I see is that the two party system has been entrenched from almost the very beginning of the country. It is hard to blame primaries, a much more recent phenomenon, for the entrenchment of the two party system that existed well over a century before primaries. Even if we want to ignore the earlier two-party systems (Federalists v. Democratic-Republicans, Democrats vs. National Republicans, Democrats vs. Whigs) and focus exclusively on Democrats vs. Republicans, it's been like that since the 1860's, again well before primaries ever existed. What has been true during all that time, however, is first-past-the-post voting, which is what entrenches the two major parties.
If anything, it seems to me it's the other way around, that primaries became entrenched because of the two-party system. When people know they have functionally only two choices, they're going to want to have more control over what those two choices are. Even worse, in many elections people functionally have only one choice, because one party is so favored over the other; for example, whoever the Democrats nominate for Senator or Governor or Representative of Hawaii is guaranteed to win, so the only decision that actually matters is who that nominee is, so the ONLY way the actual populace gets any say in that is primaries.
My argument for why binding candidate-selection primaries are bad can be found somewhere in one of my comments on James' articles about changing the process for selecting US Senators:
Other polities use first-past-the-post voting and still have had multi-party systems. Québec's recent election saw three parties (Parti Québécois, Parti libéral du Québec and Parti conservateur du Québec) all exceed 20% of the vote (none reached 30%), and another two (Québec solidaire and Coalition Avenir Québec) finish with between 10% and 15%, though the CAQ won no seats. (For reasons entirely irrelevant to this comment and entirely outside its scope, this is going to force a simmering constitutional crisis to the forefront.) In the 2024 UK election, even disregarding parties that stand candidates only in Scotland, Wales, or Northern Ireland, five parties (Labour, Conservative, Reform, Liberal Democrat and Green) won seats in England, in addition to five independents winning election (and the Speaker, against whom major parties do not stand candidates by convention). Some have converged on two-party systems, to be sure; Alberta is essentially a two-party system between the United Conservative and New Democratic parties, and Saskatchewan is a two-party system between the Saskatchewan and New Democratic parties. And it happens from time to time that minor parties displace one of the major parties; notably Labour displaced the Liberals in the UK in the 1920s. (Even the use of single-member instant runoff still produces a system with two-ish significantly dominant parties, as seen in Australia, but even there the parties representing the centre-right have changed over the years.)
Further, before the advent of primaries, the US did sometimes have more multi-party competition; see the notorious 1854-55 US House election, which saw an extremely fractured House elected (including the nascent Republican Party, which subsequently rapidly rose to prominence on being staunchly anti-slavery). That hasn't really been seen since outside of a few local exceptions (Vermont's legislature, for instance, or the example I noted of the Milwaukee Socialists). Primaries and guaranteed ballot access (in exchange for having to select candidates via primaries) further entrenched the two-party system, and in particular the two major partisan brands of Democratic and Republican, by making it easier to conduct a palace coup than make a new party electorally competitive, especially since once said new party reaches a set threshold of popular support, it becomes vulnerable to this same dynamic and can be taken over in a palace coup!
I'm not saying there aren't other factors in why US politics has become entirely focused around having only two viable parties, but binding candidate-selection primaries do seem to me to be one factor, and if you want more than two viable parties, even in the context of first-past-the-post, make it easier to become electorally viable via starting a new party than via taking over an existing one.
The Alberta separatists were just utterly trounced in a referendum on the matter, with the option to begin the process of negotiating secession receiving around 25.05% of the vote. (Every other question on the ballot, five on immigration and four on constitutional reform, saw both Yes and No receive 40% support at minimum.) Nonetheless, one of the leaders of the separatist movement, Jeffrey Rath, announced his intent to attempt to make the currently governing United Conservative Party explicitly support separatism despite its low level of popular support.
(Another prominent separatist, Mitch Sylvestre, predicted prior to the referendum that separatism would receive anywhere between 40% and 65% support. I would submit to Mr. Sylvestre that he may have forgotten that it's not just UCP supporters who got to vote in the referendum.)
The UCP promptly kicked him out of the party.
If Rath wants a pro-separatist political party in Alberta, he and other separatists can form their own party. There is no legal bar to doing that. Of course, since separatist support is concentrated in the UCP voting base, it risks splitting the vote and putting the social-democratic New Democratic Party in power in next year's election. (Not only that, but if it becomes clear that said conservative separatist party is overtaking the UCP in popular support, even some federalist conservatives might choose to vote NDP in 2027 to ensure that the government is federalist. An officially separatist UCP that still has a goodly number of federalists in the party despite that stance presents less of a risk in that regard, because conservative federalist voters might well think that the federalists who remain in the UCP caucus can restrain the separatists from doing anything too brash.) So Rath, naturally, wanted to run a palace coup on the UCP to avoid a vote split, but the UCP was able simply to rebuff his efforts, meaning, as I argued, that the easiest path to electoral relevance for his ideology is to start a new party.
If we had primary elections, on the other hand, Rath et al could turn the UCP functionally separatist by organizing to select separatist candidates in UCP primaries! The party executive might remain nominally federalist but everyone running under their banner would espouse separatism. So Rath's coup attempt could have worked there, but it couldn't work under the system we use, which is why it will be easier for him to become relevant by starting a new party than by taking over an existing one.
Also caused me to find & read your much more lengthy 2024 essay “Don’t Vote!” [So many questions here, which would be a good chat over beer(s).] I find I am both intrigued by & relatively uninformed of Catholic philosophy.
In the endnotes, you wrote: “However, I believe that, if there is hope for America, it springs from conservative roots, no matter how choked those roots may have become in recent years. I want the Right to be smart, so I will sometimes hit it pretty hard when it’s being dumb.”
I tend to believe that the hope for America (& western liberal democracy in general) is contained in the revival of (classic) liberalism as a third way - counter to both Socialism, and whatever this “conservatism” has become…).
I suppose I am Reagan-pilled enough that I view liberalism as one of the quintessentially conservative ideas! (I am certainly never going to be entirely comfortable calling the current-thing-that-calls-itself-conservatism by that name.)
I am a big fan of liberalism, and I think that it is necessary for our salvation -- although I also think it is not *sufficient.* Liberalism, in my view, is a framework for reconciling competing visions of the common good, not a view of the common good itself, and we will ultimately need *that* (operating within the liberal framework) to pull our bacon out of the fire. I'm sorry to depart, somewhat, from Freddie Hayek on this point!
"I am certainly never going to be entirely comfortable calling the current-thing-that-calls-itself-conservatism by that name."
You might appreciate the remarks made in response to Jeffrey Epstein's best friend congratulating incoming BC Premier Lorne Doerksen on his election victory:
"The MAGA-aligned party in B.C. is called One B.C. They got 1.5 percent of the vote.
"Like you, they are an embarrassment to the concept of conservatism."
(Ken Boessenkool, former advisor to Stephen Harper, in response to said congratulatory post)
Dimitri Soudas, Harper's former communications director, quoted Doerksen directly:
“B.C. and Canada are facing unacceptable threats, tariffs and rhetoric from a bully south of the border.
“You stop a bully by being strong enough that you don’t need him.”
I'm not suggesting that you'd be comfortable with Canadian conservatism, any more than you are comfortable with what's become of Epsteinland conservatism, but the former is probably less distant from your vision of conservatism than the latter.
It is highly amusing to see Epsteinland complain about foreign interference in their elections given how much Jeffrey Epstein's best friend likes to wade into elections in other countries.
Day is being much more diplomatic toward Martin than I could possibly be, because Martin clearly knows nothing about how Canadian federalism works.
(Day was only narrowly elected MLA for Courtenay-Comox, on Vancouver Island, in 2024; it appears that he has lost re-election even as his Conservative Party formed a majority government, but official results will not be known for another two weeks. What wasn't at all close was the vote on secession in the most secession-friendly Western Canadian province, where a precursor step to secession couldn't even garner 25.1% support in a referendum. We have problems, but they're our problems to solve, and we don't need Epsteinland getting its fingers in.)
If in November the Republicans do better than expected, what would you attribute it to in fore-hindsight (a word I just made up to define what you predict your own reflections will be in a stated possible future)? I agree that Schlichter's reasons stated aren't very persuasive.
There are a few trends that make me wonder if polling needs to be re-weighted or shaken up in some way. AI has increased spam calls, but it has also increased my phone's blocking abilities. Now almost every call not in my contacts list is getting sent to voicemail without even ringing to my phone. Who is getting phone polls? Could this be causing distortions in polls not yet accounted for?
Last blog you brought up people moving states to self-sort ideologically. I think that's possibly a source of drift as well.
I don't know why Republicans haven't figured out that Trump-endorsed candidates do badly in the general election on ballots Trump's name isn't on. They have had ample opportunity to learn this fact. The most likely result this November is that they will learn the lesson again. But hypotheticals are fun.
If they do a little better than expected and keep the Senate, then it's just normal polling error. The Senate map was always very favorable to Republicans, so it's ridiculous and embarrassing that it's even in play, much less that it's tilting toward the Dems. I wouldn't say that requires any more explanation than "big wave, not quite big enough, c'est la vie."
If they do way better than expected and keep the House, and there are no intervening events between then and now to explain that surprising result (like the end of the Iran War or some particularly appalling "woke" scandal on the Left)... then I'm not sure. I guess it would probably mean that the MAGA coalition really is durable now, even without Trump himself on the ballot. In that world, I would probably expect to see much higher-than-expected election day turnout in red areas, and Hispanics deciding to give Trump one more chance in light of the Democrats being so goofy. But there's so much non-polling evidence pointing at the wave that I have a hard time picturing that particular outcome.
> Who is getting phone polls? Could this be causing distortions in polls not yet accounted for?
It is always a possibility that plunging response rates will *eventually* reach a breaking point where polls just stop working. We don't seem to be there yet, but it really would be nice for more people to answer polls, because it does create this risk ever cycles that pollsters simply missed something because nobody involved would talk to them.
"Paxton’s supporters are still trying to scrape together a win from the table scraps, and they could still pull it off, since Texas is still plenty red… but Texas is not Wyoming. It is no longer a state where you can nominate any jokester with an R next to his name and expect the voters to give your guy the flag lapel (if it ever was)."
It's especially worth remembering that Alabama, which is markedly more conservative than Texas (Trump won Alabama by a good amount more than Texas), still voted in a Democratic Senator when the Republican nominee was bad enough.
Granted, Roy Moore was an even worse candidate than Ken Paxton, and the Democrats were fortunate enough that their nominee was a moderate without Talarico's baggage. If it had been Talarico vs. Paxton in Alabama back then, Paxton would have won. But because Texas isn't as staunchly Republican as Alabama, it means you don't need things to be as extreme as they were in Alabama for the Democrat to win.
I should also point out that if the Democrats had chosen a candidate without James Talarico's baggage, they'd probably actually be cruising to a victory here. Beta O'Rourke came close to beating Ted Cruz who was a much stronger candidate than Paxton; if Democrats had someone like that, they'd be in a good position, rather than the current position of it being a toss up. That said, the other choice in the primary was Jasmine Crockett who would've been a harder sell in a general election than Talarico, so Democratic voters chose the stronger candidate there. The primary system might be to blame that it came down to candidates who weren't all that great for Democrats, but at least the Democratic electorate (unlike the Republican electorate) was smart enough to choose the stronger candidate.
One thing that I don't think I've seen many comment on is that Paxton is not only dragging down the Texas election, but other elections. If John Cornyn had been the nominee, he would've beaten Talarico pretty easily, and Republican groups could have put their money and focus for other elections and other states. But because Texas is suddenly a toss up, Republican groups have to spend a bunch of money and energy to win that election... money and energy they can't spent on other races. Even if Paxton pulls off a win, his nomination still hurt Republicans in that other races became closer... and of course if he loses, it means not only did the Republicans lose a Senate seat, they ALSO harmed other races as a result.
Nitpick: You're right on the timing of the shift to selection of Presidential candidates via primary elections, but their use for selecting candidates in other US elections long predates their use in Presidential elections. Smith v. Allwright was decided in 1944, and primary elections had been in place for quite some time in many places as of that decision. (For instance, Wisconsin introduced primary elections in 1904 after approval in a statewide referendum, supported by, among others, incumbent Republican Governor Robert M. La Follette--yes, I can hear you saying that issue referenda are bad, and I wouldn't disagree with you, though I might cite different examples and reasons--and prior to that the Deep South had been using them as a way of keeping blacks from participating in selecting Democratic Party candidates, which was tantamount to barring them from the election, since that area had been on a slide toward one-party rule since the federal Congress restored passive suffrage to most of those stripped of it by the 14th Amendment.)
Primaries are still bad and have led to, as you know I've argued, the entrenchment of the two major parties in the US (though, interestingly, one of the stronger third-party presences in the US pretty much right up until McCarthyism was in Milwaukee, where Socialist candidates often won by campaigning on public-works project successes like the city's sewer system, leading other members of the Socialist Party to deride the Milwaukee socialists as "sewer socialists"; you may recognize a modern analogue with Zohran Mamdani's program to fill New York City's potholes, and he has himself drawn the comparison, calling it "pothole politics", the theory being that everyone hates potholes and it's politically difficult to make a counterargument to the proposition that spending city funds on filling potholes is good), and I get frustrated every time I see people with whom I agree on many policy questions argue for what I view as a continued undermining of necessary counterdemocratic checks via things like the introduction of binding candidate-selection primaries (in one particular case, even as she vociferously defends others, largely because, from what I can tell, the one produces policy results she dislikes and the other results she likes), but if anything they've been doing damage for much longer than you suggest here!
'tis a fair cop! I was sloppy in writing that.
(I also forgot to fact-check a claim I wrote from memory.)
It occurs to me that all you'd have to change about the sentence where you mention the origin of primary elections (aside from changing the links) is changing "help George McGovern" to "disenfranchise black voters". They have indeed since wreaked little but evil.
I have belatedly tried to edit the sentence to read:
Statewide primaries were invented to disenfranchise Black voters, nationalized simply to help George McGovern, and, naturally, have wreaked little but evil ever since.
With this footnote:
UPDATE 10 November 2026: This sentence originally read, “They were invented by the Democratic Party to help George McGovern, and, naturally, have wreaked little but evil ever since.” My right honorable friend Daniel Pareja noted in the comments that this was blending primaries au général with the binding presidential primaries that arose with the McGovern “reforms,” and suggested this expansion. I removed the slam on the Democrats because it seemed rude, at least in this context, to slam Democrats for racism they perpetrated 130 years ago.
...however, Substack is refusing the save the change. "Network issues." Hopefully it will go through in the morning.
I remember years ago seeing a Jim Crow-era voter registration form from (I think) Louisiana (maybe it was Mississippi or Alabama), probably from the 1950s or early 1960s (so after Smith v. Allwright, but before the Voting Rights Act). I didn't have the necessary cultural context to understand what was so odd about it at the time, nor did I fully appreciate the explanation that accompanied it, again because of that lack of cultural context. Sadly, I can't find said image now.
What would look odd about it to a modern viewer who does have that context is that despite the state's having partisan primaries, the voter registration form contained no place where the voter could indicate desired party affiliation. I didn't appreciate the full import of this when I saw it initially, but in retrospect of course it is clear: it was a way for election officials to ensure that the only people who got to register as members of the Democratic Party, and thus vote in its primaries (still tantamount to the general election at the time), were whites. Suffice it to say that Dixiecrats were perpetrating election racism pretty much right up until northern Democrats and Republicans forced them to stop.
Also, Bill Moyers recounted the story of Lyndon Johnson's remark about losing the South for a generation (after he signed the 1964 Civil Rights Act): https://www.theguardian.com/books/2023/jan/22/we-may-have-lost-the-south-lbj-democrats-civil-rights-act-1964-bill-moyers
“I said, ‘Quite a day, Mr President.’ As he reached a sheaf of the wire copy he tilted his head slightly back and held the copy up close to him so that he could read it, and said: ‘Well, I think we may have lost the south for your lifetime – and mine.’
“It was lightly said. Not sarcastic. Not even dramatically. It was like a throwaway sidebar.”
Moyers died in 2025.
In 2026, voters in Texas, Georgia, South Carolina, North Carolina, and possibly Mississippi elected Democratic Senators and the party made significant electoral gains across the region.
(Also apparently the North Dakota Republican Party is attempting to get rid of partisan primaries, at least in the context of how they're handled in ND, which has fully open primaries; I don't know if this is a standard Republican policy plank or something new: https://www.kxnet.com/news/top-stories/ndgop-convention-passes-14-resolutions-defining-partys-stances-moving-forward/ )
"Primaries are still bad and have led to, as you know I've argued, the entrenchment of the two major parties in the US"
Can you explain how this is the case? The problem I see is that the two party system has been entrenched from almost the very beginning of the country. It is hard to blame primaries, a much more recent phenomenon, for the entrenchment of the two party system that existed well over a century before primaries. Even if we want to ignore the earlier two-party systems (Federalists v. Democratic-Republicans, Democrats vs. National Republicans, Democrats vs. Whigs) and focus exclusively on Democrats vs. Republicans, it's been like that since the 1860's, again well before primaries ever existed. What has been true during all that time, however, is first-past-the-post voting, which is what entrenches the two major parties.
If anything, it seems to me it's the other way around, that primaries became entrenched because of the two-party system. When people know they have functionally only two choices, they're going to want to have more control over what those two choices are. Even worse, in many elections people functionally have only one choice, because one party is so favored over the other; for example, whoever the Democrats nominate for Senator or Governor or Representative of Hawaii is guaranteed to win, so the only decision that actually matters is who that nominee is, so the ONLY way the actual populace gets any say in that is primaries.
My argument for why binding candidate-selection primaries are bad can be found somewhere in one of my comments on James' articles about changing the process for selecting US Senators:
https://decivitate.jamesjheaney.com/p/replacing-the-seventeenth-amendment/comments
https://decivitate.jamesjheaney.com/p/fixing-the-senate-part-iii-your-correspondent/comments
This may be my best comment on the matter: https://decivitate.jamesjheaney.com/p/fixing-the-senate-part-iii-your-correspondent/comment/247628217
The gist is that primaries as conducted in the US destroy any possibility for ideological coherence in political parties: https://jwmason.org/slackwire/political-parties-are-illegal-in-the-united-states/
Other polities use first-past-the-post voting and still have had multi-party systems. Québec's recent election saw three parties (Parti Québécois, Parti libéral du Québec and Parti conservateur du Québec) all exceed 20% of the vote (none reached 30%), and another two (Québec solidaire and Coalition Avenir Québec) finish with between 10% and 15%, though the CAQ won no seats. (For reasons entirely irrelevant to this comment and entirely outside its scope, this is going to force a simmering constitutional crisis to the forefront.) In the 2024 UK election, even disregarding parties that stand candidates only in Scotland, Wales, or Northern Ireland, five parties (Labour, Conservative, Reform, Liberal Democrat and Green) won seats in England, in addition to five independents winning election (and the Speaker, against whom major parties do not stand candidates by convention). Some have converged on two-party systems, to be sure; Alberta is essentially a two-party system between the United Conservative and New Democratic parties, and Saskatchewan is a two-party system between the Saskatchewan and New Democratic parties. And it happens from time to time that minor parties displace one of the major parties; notably Labour displaced the Liberals in the UK in the 1920s. (Even the use of single-member instant runoff still produces a system with two-ish significantly dominant parties, as seen in Australia, but even there the parties representing the centre-right have changed over the years.)
Further, before the advent of primaries, the US did sometimes have more multi-party competition; see the notorious 1854-55 US House election, which saw an extremely fractured House elected (including the nascent Republican Party, which subsequently rapidly rose to prominence on being staunchly anti-slavery). That hasn't really been seen since outside of a few local exceptions (Vermont's legislature, for instance, or the example I noted of the Milwaukee Socialists). Primaries and guaranteed ballot access (in exchange for having to select candidates via primaries) further entrenched the two-party system, and in particular the two major partisan brands of Democratic and Republican, by making it easier to conduct a palace coup than make a new party electorally competitive, especially since once said new party reaches a set threshold of popular support, it becomes vulnerable to this same dynamic and can be taken over in a palace coup!
I'm not saying there aren't other factors in why US politics has become entirely focused around having only two viable parties, but binding candidate-selection primaries do seem to me to be one factor, and if you want more than two viable parties, even in the context of first-past-the-post, make it easier to become electorally viable via starting a new party than via taking over an existing one.
Here's a concrete example of what I'm talking about when I discuss starting a new party versus taking over an existing one: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/alberta-separatist-jeff-rath-kicked-out-governing-united-conservative-party-9.7403521
The Alberta separatists were just utterly trounced in a referendum on the matter, with the option to begin the process of negotiating secession receiving around 25.05% of the vote. (Every other question on the ballot, five on immigration and four on constitutional reform, saw both Yes and No receive 40% support at minimum.) Nonetheless, one of the leaders of the separatist movement, Jeffrey Rath, announced his intent to attempt to make the currently governing United Conservative Party explicitly support separatism despite its low level of popular support.
(Another prominent separatist, Mitch Sylvestre, predicted prior to the referendum that separatism would receive anywhere between 40% and 65% support. I would submit to Mr. Sylvestre that he may have forgotten that it's not just UCP supporters who got to vote in the referendum.)
The UCP promptly kicked him out of the party.
If Rath wants a pro-separatist political party in Alberta, he and other separatists can form their own party. There is no legal bar to doing that. Of course, since separatist support is concentrated in the UCP voting base, it risks splitting the vote and putting the social-democratic New Democratic Party in power in next year's election. (Not only that, but if it becomes clear that said conservative separatist party is overtaking the UCP in popular support, even some federalist conservatives might choose to vote NDP in 2027 to ensure that the government is federalist. An officially separatist UCP that still has a goodly number of federalists in the party despite that stance presents less of a risk in that regard, because conservative federalist voters might well think that the federalists who remain in the UCP caucus can restrain the separatists from doing anything too brash.) So Rath, naturally, wanted to run a palace coup on the UCP to avoid a vote split, but the UCP was able simply to rebuff his efforts, meaning, as I argued, that the easiest path to electoral relevance for his ideology is to start a new party.
If we had primary elections, on the other hand, Rath et al could turn the UCP functionally separatist by organizing to select separatist candidates in UCP primaries! The party executive might remain nominally federalist but everyone running under their banner would espouse separatism. So Rath's coup attempt could have worked there, but it couldn't work under the system we use, which is why it will be easier for him to become relevant by starting a new party than by taking over an existing one.
Good Fisk.
Also caused me to find & read your much more lengthy 2024 essay “Don’t Vote!” [So many questions here, which would be a good chat over beer(s).] I find I am both intrigued by & relatively uninformed of Catholic philosophy.
In the endnotes, you wrote: “However, I believe that, if there is hope for America, it springs from conservative roots, no matter how choked those roots may have become in recent years. I want the Right to be smart, so I will sometimes hit it pretty hard when it’s being dumb.”
I tend to believe that the hope for America (& western liberal democracy in general) is contained in the revival of (classic) liberalism as a third way - counter to both Socialism, and whatever this “conservatism” has become…).
https://natesilver.substack.com/p/12-questions-for-the-center-left?r=10rd8g&utm_medium=ios (definition #4 in particular)
https://natesilver.substack.com/p/why-liberalism-and-leftism-are-increasingly?r=10rd8g&utm_medium=ios
I suppose I am Reagan-pilled enough that I view liberalism as one of the quintessentially conservative ideas! (I am certainly never going to be entirely comfortable calling the current-thing-that-calls-itself-conservatism by that name.)
I am a big fan of liberalism, and I think that it is necessary for our salvation -- although I also think it is not *sufficient.* Liberalism, in my view, is a framework for reconciling competing visions of the common good, not a view of the common good itself, and we will ultimately need *that* (operating within the liberal framework) to pull our bacon out of the fire. I'm sorry to depart, somewhat, from Freddie Hayek on this point!
If you never saw Don't Vote, I'll bet you also never saw my defense of liberalism from a couple years before that, and might just enjoy it: https://decivitate.jamesjheaney.com/p/against-adrian-vermeule-ism
Thanks for reading! Glad to have you here!
Wasn't your defense of liberalism the one about not punching nazis?
Oh, that one too! I guess I like liberalism a lot.
"I am certainly never going to be entirely comfortable calling the current-thing-that-calls-itself-conservatism by that name."
You might appreciate the remarks made in response to Jeffrey Epstein's best friend congratulating incoming BC Premier Lorne Doerksen on his election victory:
"The MAGA-aligned party in B.C. is called One B.C. They got 1.5 percent of the vote.
"Like you, they are an embarrassment to the concept of conservatism."
(Ken Boessenkool, former advisor to Stephen Harper, in response to said congratulatory post)
Dimitri Soudas, Harper's former communications director, quoted Doerksen directly:
“B.C. and Canada are facing unacceptable threats, tariffs and rhetoric from a bully south of the border.
“You stop a bully by being strong enough that you don’t need him.”
I'm not suggesting that you'd be comfortable with Canadian conservatism, any more than you are comfortable with what's become of Epsteinland conservatism, but the former is probably less distant from your vision of conservatism than the latter.
https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/trump-canadian-politics-british-columbia-quebec-9.7398341
It is highly amusing to see Epsteinland complain about foreign interference in their elections given how much Jeffrey Epstein's best friend likes to wade into elections in other countries.
Incidentally, here's another example of an Epsteinland "conservative" saying really dumb stuff, and a Canadian conservative rebutting him:
https://www.rolia.net/f/4096/p10067?r631
https://www.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=122177188046462955&id=61563888661962&mibextid=wwXIfr&rdid=CXDKBmyn0DgVWFmi
Day is being much more diplomatic toward Martin than I could possibly be, because Martin clearly knows nothing about how Canadian federalism works.
(Day was only narrowly elected MLA for Courtenay-Comox, on Vancouver Island, in 2024; it appears that he has lost re-election even as his Conservative Party formed a majority government, but official results will not be known for another two weeks. What wasn't at all close was the vote on secession in the most secession-friendly Western Canadian province, where a precursor step to secession couldn't even garner 25.1% support in a referendum. We have problems, but they're our problems to solve, and we don't need Epsteinland getting its fingers in.)
If in November the Republicans do better than expected, what would you attribute it to in fore-hindsight (a word I just made up to define what you predict your own reflections will be in a stated possible future)? I agree that Schlichter's reasons stated aren't very persuasive.
There are a few trends that make me wonder if polling needs to be re-weighted or shaken up in some way. AI has increased spam calls, but it has also increased my phone's blocking abilities. Now almost every call not in my contacts list is getting sent to voicemail without even ringing to my phone. Who is getting phone polls? Could this be causing distortions in polls not yet accounted for?
Last blog you brought up people moving states to self-sort ideologically. I think that's possibly a source of drift as well.
I don't know why Republicans haven't figured out that Trump-endorsed candidates do badly in the general election on ballots Trump's name isn't on. They have had ample opportunity to learn this fact. The most likely result this November is that they will learn the lesson again. But hypotheticals are fun.
Good question! I hadn't thought about this.
It depends on how MUCH better.
If they do a little better than expected and keep the Senate, then it's just normal polling error. The Senate map was always very favorable to Republicans, so it's ridiculous and embarrassing that it's even in play, much less that it's tilting toward the Dems. I wouldn't say that requires any more explanation than "big wave, not quite big enough, c'est la vie."
If they do way better than expected and keep the House, and there are no intervening events between then and now to explain that surprising result (like the end of the Iran War or some particularly appalling "woke" scandal on the Left)... then I'm not sure. I guess it would probably mean that the MAGA coalition really is durable now, even without Trump himself on the ballot. In that world, I would probably expect to see much higher-than-expected election day turnout in red areas, and Hispanics deciding to give Trump one more chance in light of the Democrats being so goofy. But there's so much non-polling evidence pointing at the wave that I have a hard time picturing that particular outcome.
> Who is getting phone polls? Could this be causing distortions in polls not yet accounted for?
It is always a possibility that plunging response rates will *eventually* reach a breaking point where polls just stop working. We don't seem to be there yet, but it really would be nice for more people to answer polls, because it does create this risk ever cycles that pollsters simply missed something because nobody involved would talk to them.
"Paxton’s supporters are still trying to scrape together a win from the table scraps, and they could still pull it off, since Texas is still plenty red… but Texas is not Wyoming. It is no longer a state where you can nominate any jokester with an R next to his name and expect the voters to give your guy the flag lapel (if it ever was)."
It's especially worth remembering that Alabama, which is markedly more conservative than Texas (Trump won Alabama by a good amount more than Texas), still voted in a Democratic Senator when the Republican nominee was bad enough.
Granted, Roy Moore was an even worse candidate than Ken Paxton, and the Democrats were fortunate enough that their nominee was a moderate without Talarico's baggage. If it had been Talarico vs. Paxton in Alabama back then, Paxton would have won. But because Texas isn't as staunchly Republican as Alabama, it means you don't need things to be as extreme as they were in Alabama for the Democrat to win.
I should also point out that if the Democrats had chosen a candidate without James Talarico's baggage, they'd probably actually be cruising to a victory here. Beta O'Rourke came close to beating Ted Cruz who was a much stronger candidate than Paxton; if Democrats had someone like that, they'd be in a good position, rather than the current position of it being a toss up. That said, the other choice in the primary was Jasmine Crockett who would've been a harder sell in a general election than Talarico, so Democratic voters chose the stronger candidate there. The primary system might be to blame that it came down to candidates who weren't all that great for Democrats, but at least the Democratic electorate (unlike the Republican electorate) was smart enough to choose the stronger candidate.
One thing that I don't think I've seen many comment on is that Paxton is not only dragging down the Texas election, but other elections. If John Cornyn had been the nominee, he would've beaten Talarico pretty easily, and Republican groups could have put their money and focus for other elections and other states. But because Texas is suddenly a toss up, Republican groups have to spend a bunch of money and energy to win that election... money and energy they can't spent on other races. Even if Paxton pulls off a win, his nomination still hurt Republicans in that other races became closer... and of course if he loses, it means not only did the Republicans lose a Senate seat, they ALSO harmed other races as a result.
All of us readers must be so dumb, because "The Marginal Voter is Always Revenged" SLAPS as a title