Those of you who’ve been reading De Civ for a while know that one of the big background ideas I’ve been wrestling with for the past couple of years is trust.
Why did people flock to Donald Trump? They lost trust in everyone else.
Why does CPS hound parents for letting kids play alone in the front yard? They don’t trust you, your kids, or your neighbors.
Why are American cities squalid? Why the moral panic about data centers? Why is mass immigration failing? Trust, trust, and (you’re not going to believe this) also trust.
After it turned out President Biden was senile all along, I had a lovely meltdown about trust. Four years earlier, I had another meltdown about trust during the treason of the epidemiologists, and the names of those implicated in it are still dirt with me.
However, I only ever remarked on trust in passing, or in my Worthy Reads musings. I never pulled the whole thing together into a thesis. Earlier this month, the folks at Law & Liberty were kind enough to invite me to do so. No doubt you were wondering where I’ve been after such a decisive election! Law & Liberty then reminded me of their 2,000-word limit, which was a wonderful focuser for my thoughts. Check it out! Much of the article merely systematizes and provides evidence for my previous musings, but, if lots of you click, maybe they’ll invite me back! you’ll learn that there is presumably some kind of guy in a trenchcoat outside CVS selling vibrators to frustrated women a little something about the rise of totalitarianism!
“The Plexiglass Republic,” by James J. Heaney:
Most cultural changes have bounded effects. If society became more approving of, say, lesbians, we would expect to see modest changes in religiosity, sexual behavior, and sales of folk rock, but not much beyond that. Trust, on the other hand, touches every social interaction. It is tectonic. We would expect to see the effects of rising distrust open up, like fissures, in all sorts of weird places. Narrow, local forces contribute to each crack in the earth, but an observer who never looked for the deep seismic forces would miss the most important part of the story: that the ground is shifting beneath his civilization.
I cracked open the General Social Survey and found the untrusting have some rather interesting characteristics. They’re four times more likely to call life “dull,” three times more likely to be impoverished, twice as likely to say it’s unfair to bring a child into the world, believe in astrology, never vote, say it’s the government’s responsibility to “meet everyone’s needs,” and to approve of punching protesters for holding opposing views. They are 10-20 points less likely to go camping, visit an art gallery, or attend sports. They are 10-20 points more likely to say that public protests and unpopular speakers should be banned, that the rich get richer and the poor get poorer, and that immigrants are bad for America. I could go on.
And, indeed, I do go on! Read the whole thing!
I’ve even got a soundtrack for you! The piece was originally titled “The Paranoia Blues,” so this (rather obscure) Paul Simon track has been stuck in my head for three weeks:
P.S. If you’re curious how my last piece at Law & Liberty turned out, Michael C. Munger wrote a response to me (and others) in “Zoning and the American Way”.
DE CIV NEXT VOYAGE: This L&L article, though short, was very intense (General Social Survey correlations don’t read themselves!), so I’m not sure I’ll manage to get a fresh De Civ post up before December 1—but I am going to try! I do owe subscribers a Worthy Reads, so that’s my top priority, but I have a couple other articles that are closer to finished. Thanks for your patience and support!

